Thanksgiving Tea Pairings: What to Serve With Dinner and Pie
Thanksgiving tea pairings for every part of the meal: a pot for arriving guests, teas that stand up to turkey and gravy, and the best cups…
Country, language & currency
or
The Tea Journal · Black Tea · Herbal Tea
By the Tealyra Tea Team · · 5 min read

In short: a Christmas dinner wants three pots of tea. Start with a fragrant black tea such as a cream Earl Grey while people arrive, pour a strong, brisk black tea or a lightly smoked Lapsang Souchong with the turkey and trimmings, and finish with a spiced or chocolate-mint cup for the pudding, mince pies and cheese board. Brew 2.5 to 3 g per 250 ml, water at 95 to 100 °C for black teas, 3 minutes in the pot, and keep a caffeine-free rooibos going for the evening.
Tea has always been part of a British Christmas, but it usually turns up only at the end, in a mug, once the washing up is done. It deserves better. A well-chosen pot cuts through goose fat and bread sauce, refreshes the palate between courses and gives the driver and the children something as festive as everyone else's glass. Here is how we pair loose leaf tea with each stage of the day.
The first pot should be aromatic and easy to drink without milk, something that fills the hallway with scent as the door opens. Cream Earl Grey is ideal: bergamot for brightness, vanilla for warmth.
Cream Earl Grey Moonlight is a black tea base with bergamot, vanilla and blue cornflowers. Brew it at 95 °C, 3 g per 250 ml, 3 minutes, and serve it plain in small cups. If someone wants a treat, pour a strong cup over warm frothed milk for a London Fog. The rest of our Earl Grey range works just as well here, from classic to French.

Roast turkey, pigs in blankets, roast potatoes, bread sauce, stuffing and gravy are heavy, salty and rich. The tea has to have body and a bit of grip, or it disappears. Two styles do the job.
Goose and duck, both fattier than turkey, are better with the Lapsang. A nut roast or a mushroom Wellington wants the malty tea, which picks up the browned, savoury notes. Our black tea collection has both styles in loose leaf.
This is the course where tea shines. Christmas pudding, brandy butter, mince pies and a slab of Stilton are sweet, boozy and fatty all at once, and a warm cup makes each bite taste fresher than a glass of anything cold.

| Dish | Tea | Why it works |
|---|---|---|
| Christmas pudding and brandy butter | Spiced black tea or chai | Cinnamon, clove and ginger in the cup echo the pudding's own spices. |
| Mince pies | Cream Earl Grey | Bergamot lifts the dried fruit; vanilla matches the pastry. |
| Yule log, chocolate puddings | Chocolate Mint Rooibos | Cocoa and peppermint, caffeine-free, so it suits a late slice. |
| Stilton, cheddar, cheese board | Lapsang Souchong | Smoke against salty blue cheese is as classic as port, without the headache. |
| Trifle, cream desserts | Plain strong black tea | Clean and brisk against sponge, custard and cream. |
Chocolate Mint Rooibos deserves a special mention. It is a South African red bush blend with cocoa nibs and peppermint, naturally caffeine-free and naturally sweet, so it is the pot everyone can keep drinking at 10 pm. Brew it 5 to 6 minutes at 100 °C; rooibos never turns bitter. The rest of our rooibos range, including a rooibos chai, works the same way.
If you would rather have the spice already in the leaf, our post on spiced Christmas teas and mulled tea covers blends that go with the pudding course on their own, and our herbal tea range has peppermint and ginger blends for after the meal.
A spiced black tea or a chai, so the cinnamon, clove and ginger in the cup match the pudding. If it is late, a chocolate mint rooibos is a caffeine-free alternative that still tastes festive.
A strong, malty black tea such as Assam or English Breakfast, brewed 3 minutes and served without milk. For goose, duck or anything smoked, a Lapsang Souchong is the better match.
Yes, and many hosts now serve both. Tannin in black tea cleans the palate the way acidity in wine does, and a pot of Lapsang alongside the cheese board stands in for port surprisingly well.
Allow two cups each over the meal, around 20 cups or four six-cup pots, which is roughly 50 to 60 g of leaf across two or three different teas.
Rooibos has no caffeine at all. A chocolate mint or spiced rooibos keeps the festive flavours without keeping anyone awake, and it does not turn bitter if the pot sits.
Thanksgiving tea pairings for every part of the meal: a pot for arriving guests, teas that stand up to turkey and gravy, and the best cups…

Darjeeling first flush vs second flush: how spring and summer pickings differ in colour, taste and strength, how to brew each, and which…

A UK tea drinker's Black Friday shortlist: which loose leaf teas and teaware are worth buying, how much tea to stock up on, and what to…